BMI is no longer the best measurement for obesity

A panel of experts has recommended a new method to diagnose and treat obesity. A report published in The Lancet Diabetes & Endocrinology recommends that patients are diagnosed as either clinically obese or pre-clinically obese depending on a combination of factors including their BMI, their fat distribution and whether they are suffering health consequences as a result of their weight. It is hoped this new framework will provide patients with better access to appropriate treatment.


Traditionally obesity has been defined as a BMI of more than 30. However, this does not take into account whether an individual has fat distribution around their belly (high risk of heart disease) or around their hips (lower risk). Nor does it assess the impact that weight is having on an individual – do they have joint pain? Are they breathless? Do they have heart failure?